David Krein

Head of Research

Trade frequency: More ways this isn't your father's bond market

After several years of record-low interest rates and an unprecedented wave of issuance, today's bond market is unlike anything that has come before it. We've ballooned to over $8 trillion in U.S. high grade and high yield corporate bond debt outstanding while pushing overall bond market turnover to an all-time low during the same period.

As we've noted before in High Grade Turnover: A Closer Look at That All-Time Low, such a broad brush fails to uncover the micro-structure dynamics of this new market environment. Understanding these micro-structure dynamics takes on particular importance in a period of increased volatility, continued high levels of issuance, and regulatory scrutiny of institutional portfolios' liquidity.

As we've noted, in HG, the "liquid" segment of the market – that's roughly the 1,000 most active CUSIPs – has maintained its historical turnover. The less liquid segment – that's all other CUSIPs – has not, weighed down by the crush of securities that need to be priced each month. This nuance is lost when looking at market-wide measures.

Of course, turnover is just one measure and the above-mentioned approach is just one filter.

Chart 1 shows the daily average U.S. high grade trading activity for 2015. We've counted 5,217 unique CUSIPs reported to TRACE (and aggregated via BondTicker) on an average day, including both Client-Dealer (C-D) trades and Dealer-Dealer (D-D) trades of any size. That number falls a modest 2% to 5,084 when looking at just C-D trades.

However, that number falls an additional 57% to 2,194 when looking at CUSIPs with at least one C-D on each side of the market; e.g. one client buy and one client sell. Stated differently, 57% of CUSIPs appearing on TRACE have just one-sided C-D trading on a typical day.

Chart 1 also shows comparable statistics for CUSIPs with at least five trades and at least ten trades.

We've counted a daily average of 1,030 CUSIPs with at least five C-D trades on a given day, or 20% of those with at least one C-D trade. And 154 of these CUSIPs have at least five C-D trades on both sides of the market, which is just 3% of those with at least one C-D trade.

The data for ten trades is even thinner: an average of 341 CUSIPs have at least ten C-D trades on a given day, and just 22 CUSIPs have at least ten C-D trades on both sides of the market on a given day.

Chart: HG Trading Activity January 2016
Click to Enlarge

Chart 2 shows the same analysis for the U.S. high yield market. There were 1,649 unique CUSIPs traded on average each day, 97% of which appeared in the C-D market. But when we look at two-way activity, the number drops 45% to 889 unique CUSIPs traded. The decline is even greater for CUSIPs that traded at least 10 times a day. As with the U.S. investment grade market, the results are quite thin: 143 CUSIPs have at least ten C-D trades on a given day, and just 11 CUSIPs have at least ten C-D trades on both sides of the market on a given day.

Chart: HY Trading Activity January 2016
Click to Enlarge

Mapping trade frequency underscores the discontinuity of liquidity in what is a radically different bond market than a decade ago. More than ever, the market is a collection of micro market structures with highly differentiated liquidity characteristics. Not surprisingly, today's market participants find increasing value in deploying a spectrum of trading protocols to engage with the broadest range of counterparties possible.

Email The Author
 
Bond Trading Roupie

Europe's Bond Trading enters a New Evolution
Christophe Roupie, Head of Europe and Asia at MarketAxess, talks evolving dynamics within fixed income markets, the impact of MiFID II, electronic trading’s inflexion point and Brexit one year out.
See Full interview



Technology Transforming a Vast Corporate Bond Market


Technology Transforming a Vast Corporate Bond Market
"84% of Investment-Grade investors utilize electronic trading, accounting for 20% of overall volume" and MarketAxess is leading the pack in market share and penetration according to Greenwich Associates research.
Download the full report

 



@MarketAxess on Twitter

This information is provided "AS IS." Although the data presented has been obtained or compiled from sources MarketAxess® believes to be reliable, MarketAxess® cannot and does not warrant, either expressly or impliedly, the accuracy, validity, timeliness or completeness of this information, or its suitability for any particular purpose.